Add a Comment

Comment by Bruce Evans on September 7, 2011 at 11:03

I learned to play guitar during the “Folk Music Scare” and the “British Invasion” of the 60s here in the U.S. I also became interested in jazz while I was in college and that still has some influence on my playing today. I play in standard tuning. I have briefly – very briefly – experimented with drop D and DADGAD but I haven’t found enough attraction to cause me to continue, perhaps because I play my guitar in other styles in addition to Irish Trad. I play mostly with a flat pick in a rhythmic and occasionally syncopated style, although I do accompany myself in fingertstyle on a few ballads with perhaps an instrumental interlude between sung verses. I play mostly an alternating bass line along with short connecting scale passages.

 

In accompanying fiddle tunes during a session, I play mostly first position open chords, but here’s where that jazz influence starts to creep in. I love playing 7^th chords where I can, and I learned in jazz that a minor 7^th chord whose root is the 5^th of a dominant 7^th chord can be “substituted” for the dom 7^th. I don’t often completely substitute the minor 7^th, but rather just precede the dominant chord with the minor 7^th. For example:

D D G G  A7 A7  D D

will become

D D G G Em7 A7 D D

 

The jazz influence also shows up in my choice of “color” chords. In our sessions there is almost always more than one guitar player. I will not debate the merits or pitfalls of that now. That’s just the way it is here. When I feel the need to enhance the tonal variety I will play a color chord which does not clash with what the other backup musicians are playing. For instance, if the tune is in G I might play a G6 chord. Major 7^th and Add 9 chords also fit into that bag of tricks.

 

OK, I have so much more I could write, but that's enough for now. How do you do it? 

Comment by Bruce Evans on August 31, 2011 at 15:03

Davy, when I started this group I also wanted to start a parallel group called Trad Melody Guitar (or solo, or something similar). The site administrator suggested we go with just one group to begin with, and I agreed. I called this one Backup guitar because I have seen on other sites where the subject is Irish/Celtic guitar the DADGAD fingerstyle players seem to take over and speak disparagingly of the "strummers," and effectively discourage those people from participating. 

 

I love the solo style of playing but I wanted to have a place where it is OK to ask about first position chords and strumming patterns. At least on our side of the pond, that is how guitar is played most often in sessions. So please post as you will and I hope that there is enough participation to create that other group. 

Comment by Davy Rogers on August 28, 2011 at 20:15

I thought I'd add an example here of guitar as a melody and backing instrument (fingerstyle) using DADGAD and standard EADGBE tunings. Maybe this isn't the place for this as the title of this group is "Trad. Backup Guitar". I thought I'd add this anyway to demonstrate how the guitar can be used for melody playing along with an integral bassline. If anyone's interested in finding out more about fingerstyle guitar, may I suggest browsing my website: Davy Rogers' Traditional Irish Guitar TABs and MIDIs

guitarist Donal Clancy playing "Garret Barry's" and "The Humours of...

 

guitarist Jean Barnwarth playing "The Blackbird"

Comment by Bruce Evans on August 28, 2011 at 17:35

My apologies to those who had to wait  few days for group approval. I have been at a music festival since last Thursday. I am home now and I think I have caught up with my duties.

Comment by Tradconnect Reviews on August 25, 2011 at 16:40

I will see if I can get any contact details. Don't hold your breath though.

Comment by Bruce Evans on August 25, 2011 at 12:09

I just listened to the video a couple times and Mr. Courell certainly isn't playing the melody of tune - perhaps an improvised counter melody. Tony, is it possible you could contact Mr. Courell and have him contribute as a visiting expert?

Comment by Bruce Evans on August 25, 2011 at 11:40

Tony, do you think he is playing melody, not chordal backup? When the tune starts he seems to be actively listening as if he isn't familiar with the it.

Comment by Tradconnect Reviews on August 25, 2011 at 10:11

Bruce 

The second guitar player is Declan Courell who I went to school with many years ago. A fine player now. Saw him at the Fleadh again this year. Pretty sure he plays in DADGAD which lends itself to a much more quieter style of playing, with the melody being picked out a lot rather than the straight rythmn of the 1st. 

Comment by Bruce Evans on August 24, 2011 at 16:59

I chose the videos below to demonstrate two different styles. In the first video the guitar player seems to be playing in standard tuning using first position chords. I am guessing from what I hear as his fretting hand isn't visible. He is strumming most of the strings with each pick stroke in a simple pattern. 

 

In the second video the guitar player - who unfortunately is not at the best camera angle either - is in some kind of "mostly open" tuning, perhaps DADGAD. I have arrived at this conclusion by noting that the tune is in D and he slides his capo above the nut when he joins in and plays mostly open strings. He changes chords, or at least fingerings, much more often than the first player. 

 

I am trying to make these observations without bias towards or against either. I have a couple other styles I would like to discuss also, but I do not have video examples yet. For now, is either of these two styles common in your area? I am going to guess that there are yet others which you would like to reference. Please do so with video examples if you can. Personally, I am somewhere between those two styles and a fair bit to one side. (I have no idea what that means.)

 

 

Comment by Bruce Evans on August 24, 2011 at 16:45

First, let me post a couple videos for examples;

http://www.livetrad.com/Videos/ffleadh/index.php

http://www.livetrad.com/Videos/shoots2/index.php

 

• ‹ Previous
• 1
• 2
• 3
• Next ›
• Page